Choose
one object now in a museum. Describe, analyse and discuss the
object’s biography and social life since its production.
In this essay, I will study an object’s life under the prism of
its social, cultural, financial and religious effects on the people.
By choosing the Icon of Annunciation from the Orthodox Christian
tradition, I will prove that not only objects in the museums require
attention of observation and admiration but also objects with personality
are capable to define their own destiny, regardless the place and
time they ‘live’. Observing through the different step of object’s
lifecycle, I will present the facts how any object can influence
people’s beliefs, lifestyles, environment and way of thinking.
The essay gradually focuses on the icon by going through the general
concept of objects’ life and their impact on the society in a Material
Culture.
“Material Culture” is term used for ‘thing’, ‘specimen’, ‘artecraft’,
‘good’, and object collectively. But every object, thing, good
or artecraft shows us entirely different world of knowledge depending
upon the tradition of study. Material Culture is a broaden frame
that covers almost everything from a plant to a song. “Material
Culture is that segment of man’s physical environment which is
purposely shaped by him according to a culturally dedicated plan”
If explained otherwise, material culture covers whole cultural
expression, one way or another. It is primarily a cultural value
that makes an object a ‘moveable piece’ and how and with what process
was used to create or form that object becomes secondary or most
of the times remains irrelevant.
To understand more about objects we may look at Pearce, defining
the object in the following text: “Objects are lumps of the material
world. They share this nature with all living things, including
ourselves, and this materiality distinguishes all that share it
from insubstantial creations like tunes, poems, or the idea of
marriage. Like ourselves, objects can only be in one place at any
given time.” Objects
‘live’ life like us and may have longer lifespan with complex lifecycles.
Pearce gives an example of typical lifecycle. “Objects can have
complicated life cycles in which part of their time is passed in
enjoying some kind of regard, part as garbage or semi-garbage in
discard dumps or junk heaps, and part resurrected by archaeological
processes or by shifts in taste, to be reinstated in museum collections
and the like. Ultimately, however, they die, suddenly in accident,
war or act of God, or gradually through the slow processes of decay.”
Objects carry information about their time, space and significance
they bear at that particular time. Objects
enjoy great significance and importance in the society and this
‘translates’ the society’s own individuality of thoughts and culture.
As Janet Hoskins narrates in the following quotation: “But the
use of an icon, a concrete vehicle for our thoughts, is of course
common across the divide of cultural differences.” Objects,
in cultural prospective, are the commodities that are not only
produced materially but also culturally marked as being certain
kind of things. The same thing or object can be considered as commodity
at one time and not at another.
Icons are the objects with special meanings and characteristics
in Orthodox Christian tradition. The word ‘icon’ has number of
meanings in art history, art criticism, linguistic and semiotics.
Some authors used the Greek word ‘eikon’ or ‘ikon’ to indicate
the specific meaning it belongs to. “The Greek word eikon can be
translated as ‘image, picture, portrait, representation’. The modern
use of the word denotes two-dimensional representations such as
paintings, photographs, or pictures in magazines and newspapers,
and three-dimensional objects such as statues. In certain contexts
the word refers particularly to pictures, are regarded by members
of the Orthodox Christian Church as sacramental. An Icon is a mysterion,
a sacred mystery, a sacrament. It is sacramental in two senses,
being both a result and a means of consecration.” Icon,
as mentioned above, is physical object painting on wood, which
can be carried around. The icon could be an image of a holy person
or a seen from the holy writings or both. Icons
composition reflects the relationship of the created world to its
Creator.
A representative paradigm which shows the power that an icon has
over the religious people is the Annunciation’s icon in Tinos Island
in Greece.(Fig. 3) The reason that makes this icon so unique is
how it came into our possession. On 9th July 1822 a nun called
Pelagia from the Kechrovouniou Monastery on Tinos, had a vision.
She dreamt of the Holy Virgin. She gave her specific instructions
on where she should dig in order to discover her home and her icon
otherwise the island would be infected by cholera. Because she
was so humble to believe that the Holy Virgin ‘visited’ her in
her dream, she didn’t follow Holly Virgin’s orders. But
the dreams continued. After the third vision and under Sister Pelagia’s
guidance, the local inhabitants started excavations. Two months
later the only thing that they had discovered was the remains of
a Palaiochristianic church of Saint John which had been burnt down
by Sarakin Pirates in 1200 A.D. Finally they abandoned their efforts
and the cholera spread like wild fire over the island. This
was strong evidence that they should continue digging devotedly
and on 30th January 1823 they brought the icon of the Annunciation
of Mother of God to the light. After
the Megalochari icon was found, the islanders decided to build
a large church. Marble columns from the ancient temples of Delos
and Poseidon at Kionia (on Tinos) were used in the construction,
as was local marble from the quarries of Panormos. The news of
the icon’s discovery spread quickly through Greece, and almost
every ship passing Tinos with a load of lime, timber, or other
building materials docked there to donate part of its cargo to
the construction effort. Volunteer workers came from distant parts
of Greece. All
the population of the island helped. Wealthy and poor, lords and
loon, local and foreigners, women and children were working day
and night with zeal and enthusiasm. The construction of the church
was sponsored by rich people who were giving their money and jewelery
and by poor people who worked voluntarily. Even the women and the
children were helping by transferring building materials.
The Greek nation was so devoted and so passionate about the building
of the temple, which would be the ‘home’ of the Holy Icon, that
not only the indigenous but also people from all around Greece
and abroad; wherever Hellenism existed. The most impressive thing
was that the temple was ready in a year. With pure “Aegean” expression
the two floor building is influenced by the Byzantine temples of
Constantinople and by the Post-Byzantine Cycladic churches. Beyond
the monasteric structure of the temple there
was a great contribution of artists who ‘perked up’ the building
complex and they ‘infused’ Tinos with a new identity: from the
Island of Faith it became also Island of Art. (Fig.
7) In 1984 A. Nicolas (a Greek Cypriot) translated and published
some articles of newspapers during the period 1842-1885 which were
related to Greece and especially to Tinos. Among others he says:
‘While we are approaching Tinos the most magnificent spectacle
is the famous temple of Panagia. It is made of marble and because
of its snow-white colour is shining. The monastery, the yards,
the gardens and the main bell-tower, which has 130 feet height,
take up a lot of space… After Holy Places and the Athos, the church
of Holy Mary is the temple that Greek people respect the most.
Every year a mass of pilgrims gather from all around the world
and there are numerous of narrations about miracles that achieved
with the ‘help’ of Holy Mary. The main entrance, the yards and
the loggias all around have familiar style with Mosques of Constantinople,
which all of them have of course Hagia Sophia as a prototype. The
church is full of precious offerings. From the centre of the painted
dome a huge pure silver chandelier is hanging and innumerous small
lamps of the same valuable material are all around’.
The icon, that was found, was the Annunciation. Although the shovel
of the worker cut the icon into two pieces, the forms of Archangel
Gabriel and Holy Mary were sustained untouched. The backside of
the icon is burned. The main hypothesis is that the icon was kept
initially in the Palaiochristianic church of Saint John which was
burned (part of the foundation can be seen in the basement of the
church). Thanks
to humidity the icon was preserved until 1823. The gold and valuable
stones, offerings by pilgrims, cover the mark that was provoked
by the shovel. On the first pilgrimage, the duchesses of Tinos
put every precious thing they had with them on the mark in order
to cover it.(Fig.
1)
In the copy of the icon that is kept in the vestry of Holy Foundation
the Megalochari is presented praying on her knees with head bowed.
She is wearing a long colored dress (golden, yellow, green), standing
in front of small and short lectern, where each surface is covered
with golden and yellow fabric. The neckwear is tied up in the same
way the daughters of Nazaret were wearing. The words that are mumbled
by Panagia after the Annunciation are written in the book that
is placed on the lectern: “IDOU I DOULI SOU KYRIOU GENOITO MOI
KATA TO RIMA SOU.” Deep
inside the room we see windows on both sidewalls and top middle
of the icon we can see the Holy Spirit with appearance of a pigeon
in a shaft of light. In front of the virgin Marry facing her with
the same colored dress, the Archangel Gabriel stands gleaming and
full of spirit holding a lily in his left hand, which symbolizes
virginity. (Fig.
2)
“Some historians date this icon to a period earlier than Byzantium,
possibly the first half of second century of Christianity.”
Many of the scholars who had studied the icon classified it among
the first three works of Evangelist Lucas. Moreover they claim
that wonder-working hypostasis derives from the blessing of the
Holy Marry. On
the other hand, many others argue that “this is considered to be
only a pious hope of local Christians; it was not stated by the
Mother of God during her appearances to sister Pelagia, nor are
there any other clues to the icon’s origin. Nevertheless it is
wonder-working icon, and since its discovery thousands of verified
miracles have been reported by those who have prayed before it
for the intercession of the Mother of God.”
Despite the turbulent past of the icon, it had eventful future.
“Sadly, in 15th of December, 1842 the
icon was stolen by Christodoulos Dimitriadis, a young Greek criminal
passing through Tinos. As it is today the icon was then covered
with golden precious stones given in thanksgiving for answered
prayers. Dimitriadis hid in one of the overhanging balconies, waiting
for the church to close. After dark he lowered himself by a rope
and fled with the chalice, altar utensils, and the wonder-working
icon. When the loss was discovered the following morning, church
bells tolled mournfully throughout the island, announcing the theft.
Patrols were organized in all the villages and Dimitriadis was
caught at noon, trying to escape with his stolen goods across the
narrow straits separating Tinos and Andros. The recovery of the
icon was a cause of general Rejoicing and the Megalochari was triumphantly
returned to its place in the Cathedral.”
The icon of Annunciation is appreciated with love, worship and
reputation just because of one reason, the Miracle. The Miracle
that made Tinos a symbol. The Miracle that, people believe, comforts
and makes promises. The reactions of the pilgrims can even reach
the edges. They, in their ecstasy, lie on their knees, pray with
tears and ache for their own salvation. The
pilgrimage in Panagia of Tinos and the faith in the icon’s miracles
are not only the poor people’s ‘privilege’. The impressive offerings
and jewelry declare the deep devotion to Panagia from the wealthy
also. The phasma
of offerings, from the most humble to the most precious, shows
that the church attracts the believers from every corner of the
world regardless their religious beliefs, age, gender, ethnicity
and social background.
Since the discovery of the icon innumerous and renowned miracles
have been recorded. It is crucial to refer to the few characteristic
miracles that have been recorded in order to understand the charismatic
power of the icon. The most famous of the tamata,
which can be unnoticed from the visitors, is “a model of a ship
made of gold and silver with a fish hanging out of the breech.
Around the mid-1850s, a ship sailing in the Mediterranean, met
with the cyclone. The ship’s crew struggled to keep the vessel
afloat, but the stormy waves forced a breach in the hold and the
ship begun to sink. Bailing and pumping, the frantic crew prayed
fervently to the Mother of God and finally managed to sail the
listing ship to harbor. As they begun to repair the damage caused
by the storm, they found to their amazement that a huge fish has
swum into the breach of the ship and was trapped so tightly that
it had stopped the influx of water. The crew immediately saw the
hand of the Mother of God in this and in thanksgiving sent the
church this model”(Fig.
4)
Another well known votive offering is a silver orange tree with
the hanging vigil candles from its branches. “A Greek-American
lost his sight after a serious illness. He had heard about the
miracles performed for people who prayed before the icon ‘of Great
Joy’ and begged to Mother of God to restore his sight, promising
to offer her the first thing he saw. God’s grace manifested the
virgin’s prayers, and when he regained his sight, the first thing
he saw was a beautiful orange tree. The meticulously crafted miniature
of the tree can be seen to the right of main doors of the church
of the Annunciation.”(Fig.
5)
“It is not only among the orthodox that God’s grace acts for those
who pray to Virgin. In the 19th century, a Turkish mïslem colonel
who suffered from an incurable disease visited the icon and asked
the prayers of the Mother of God. He was healed and out of gratitude
constructed the marble fountain near the staircase leading to the
church. The water in this fountain is blessed every year on Theophany.”
Because the main character of this story was Turkish and because
the majority of recent Greek state was extracted from Turkey, this
story attains special meaning as recognition of Panagia’s Icon’s
power (for Orthodoxy and Greek nation in general).
The faith in Megalochari of Tinos enforced and set its roots up
with miracles and with the verification of the words of Evangelistria.
It reminds us the miracles of Christ and the confirmative of his
words which enforced the faith into Him and the Christianity. Millions
of pilgrims have testified their entreaty, blessing, happiness,
hope, pain, cry and the Tama for a miracle, devotionally
to Her. The diachronic attraction of Megalochari to Her pilgrims
is illuminated by their countless offerings to the icon, in the
temples of ‘Evresi’ and
‘Evangelistria’. The overwhelming religious feelings of the pilgrims,
that could be seen through the offerings from ‘two cents of widow’
to priceless diamonds, provide, in parallel, the valuable historical
validation to the very complicated and diachronic of Megalochari;
the Annunciation.(Fig.
6)
The discovery of the icon of Megalochari in Tinos Island, on 30th
January, 1823 was a determinative fact for the reborned Greek state.
The Pelagia’s vision ‘came’ in a very crucial moment of the Greek
history because almost one year before that vision the Independence
war had started. The
finding of the Holy Icon was an omen of the Holy acquiescence to
the titanic strangle. The
Greek Revolution had begun on 25th of March, 1821, the anniversary
of Annunciation. After four hundred years of Turkish occupancy
the Greek revolutionists chose that day to start their resistance.
Since then this day is celebrated in Greece with dual importance.
In other words, this day combines two rebirths: the humanity and
the Greeks. The
finding of the Holy icon includes also the idea of resurrection.
The history is repeated, as it happens in the history of Annunciation,
a Holy being, Panagia, talks to a virgin, the old and moral sister
Pelagia. The virgin Pelagia becomes the body of the rebirth of
Greek nation according to the symbolism of the finding of the Holy
Icon, such as Holy Marry became the carrier for the humanity’s
renaissance. Moreover the icon which used to be accommodated in
Byzantine temple was buried due to pillages of the barbarians.
For all the aforementioned, the Panagia of Tinos and Her miraculous
icon acquired important national and universal diastasis and transformed
into a center of attraction for the Orthodox of all around the
world.
Evangelistria was the ‘Prostate God’ of Revolution, the faith which
had predetermined its success. The enslaved Greek nation based
its hopes for freedom on Her, it strongly believed that Panagia
would protected its struggle and that She would guarantee the positive
outcome of the war. She
‘kept Her promise’ and for that reason, after the foundation of
the first Greek State in 1832, many participants of the War felt
obliged to go to Tinos and pay their honours to Her Grace. Among
the first pilgrims were Konstantinos Kanaris, Miaoulis, Karaiskakis,
Makrigiannis, Kolokotronis and many others. Panagia
was always considered to be a national symbol. Until 1922, when
The Catastrophe of Asia Minor and the Separation of the eastern
part of Greece by the Turkey happened, the temple epitomised the
main patriotic and religious index mark. This was very obvious
especially in the days of temple’s celebrations: Icon’s Finding
day (30 January), Annunciation’s day (25 March), Saint Pelagias
day (23 July) and Dormition (15 Augoust), when the island was flooded
with a vast concourse of prayers and with an atmosphere of emotive
manifestations of national elan. From
the day of Icon’s Finding until now, political personages, Kings,
Presidents of Democracy, Prime Ministers, Cabinet Ministers and
several other representatives of the State come along not only
to revere but also to express their gratefulness to the Guardian
of the Nation.
Another characteristic paradigm, which empowers the belief that
the icon has been the guardian angel of the Hellenism, is the torpedo
of the war craft ‘ELLI’. The ship was moored in the port of Tinos
in order to do honours to the Megalochari’s celebration on 15th
August 1940. It was considered as a miracle because thousands of
people were saved by definite death. Panagia
of Tinos was regarded to protect the Greek army in the Albanian
War, led it into a triumph and saved the Greek Nation. In December
of the same year Panagia of Tinos, through its Foundation, had
a great contribution in the needs of war and generally in the salvation
of Greece. The Foundation disposed temples and Holy Icon’s valuables
and the jewellery. In the 20th March, 1945, when the Anniversary
of National Independence was celebrated for the first time, the
government ordered the transportation of the Holy Icon with all
the proper honours in the capital of Greece, Athens, so as to enlighten
the celebration and to enable every citizen to express his adoration
and his thanksgivings towards the Patron of the nation.
Before analysing the general contribution of the Panellenic Holy
Foundation of Evagelistria of Tinos, it is important to mention
the financial section. The pilgrimage is supposed to be a major
perspective. Apart from the wealth that is in the church’s disposal,
part of which returns to the locals as charity, a big amount of
people, who live there, are depended, directly or indirectly, on
the pilgrimage to cover their expenses. The pilgrims rent rooms,
eat in restaurants, buy local goods and souvenirs, tickets for
the buses and the ships, and play, in general, an important role
in the island’s economy giving rise to the domestic agriculture
and establishing new work positions for the natives. The
major part of local businesses is providing services to the pilgrims
and most of them are completely depended on that.
The Holy Foundation of Evagelistria has a national, religious,
educational, charitable, social activity which can be considered
as exemplary for every typical foundation. The
administration of the Foundation contributed radically in the field
of education, art, culture and in several beneficial activities.
Tinos managed to have educational system in really tough periods
for the Hellenism (Independence War: 1821-1823, Kapodistrian period:
1828-1831, Othonian period: 1833-1862), which was considered to
be a major achievement. Since 1823, the potentates of Tinos had
established a school in church’s yard in their own expenses. This
was only the beginning. The Foundation supported opening of many
more schools after that; it also offered huge amount of money (in
comparison to the financial reality of that time) for the buildings,
conservation of schools, hiring and payments of teachers, buying
books etc. The phileducational action of the foundation continues
since then.
But the Foundation’s cultural and social presence extends in many
other sections beyond education. In the yard of the temple, the
owners established a remarkable library with old and rare publishing
and also archaeological collection in 1824. This initial effort
developed into the contemporary impressive and valuable museums
which can be visited in the monastery and in the Centre of Tinos.
Furthermore the committees have never stopped establishing and
conserving charitable institutes and schools (Music School, Silk
Textile Industry School, Biotechnical School, High School, School
of Fine Art of Panormos, Holy Icon Paintings School, and School
of Byzantine Music). They also continued supporting missions, monasteries,
orphanages, higher and technical education institutes (e.g. University
of Athens in 1833) and, later in 1840, they started scholarships
for outstanding artists, painters, sculptors such as Nik. Gyzis,
Nik. Lytras, Gian. Chalepas and many others. In addition, they
funded to construct infrastructure for the island (port, roads,
water supply, electricity etc.). They extended their support for
the battles of the nation, armada and to help refugees of Crete
and Asia Minor. All
the aforementioned where achieved with the money derived from the
pain, the faith and the hope of humble and stormed people.
All the above mentioned facts underline the divergence
of another ever happening miracle in Tinos island; that composed
the multiform activity of the Institute - national, religious,
educational, charitable and social - that surrounds not only Greece
but also the Greeks all over the world. The
Holy Virgin’s Icon’s Finding was a crucial point for the island.
It upgraded it mentally and financially, it transformed it into
a centre of pilgrimage and in the recent Greek history, Tinos was
recorded as “the Panagia’s Island”. This
Icon is a representative example of an object outside of museum
which had earned the glory and fame on its own. Not only it had
earned the religious respect by a nation but also it had ‘paid
back’ by supporting, giving hopes, encouraging and inspiring it.
Although the creator had just paid honour to a religious miracle
by this Icon, the objects chose its destiny and became a miracle
by itself.

Fig. 1: The Annunciation Icon with the jewelry in the Temple of
Evengelismos in Tinos.(McLees, Mother Nectaria, ‘The Tinos Icon
of Great Joy’, Road
to Emmaus, 10 (Summer 2002), Portland, USA. http://www.roadtoemmaus.net)

Fig. 2: Copy of the Holy Icon
Panellenik Holy Foundation of Evangelistiria of Tinos, Perigrafi
Tis Evresis Tis Thavmatourgou Agias Ikonas Tis Evangelistrias Stin
Tino To Etos 1823 (Description of the Finding of the Miraculous
of Holy Icon of Evangelistria of Tinos in 1823)*, (Tinos: PHFET Press,
2006)

Fig. 3: The first shrine of the Holy Icon.
(Calendar
2006 of Panhellenic Holy Foundation of Evangelistria of Tinos)

Fig. 4: The Ship with the fish, ‘Tama’ for a miracle.
Amiralis,
George N., Tiniakes Antavgies. Istoria-Laografia (Tinos’
Shimmers. History -Laography)* (Athens: Tinos, 1996)

Fig. 5: Orange Tree, ‘Tama’ for a miracle
Amiralis,
George N., Tiniakes Antavgies. Istoria-Laografia (Tinos’
Shimmers. History -Laography)* (Athens: Tinos, 1996)

Fig. 6: Pilgrims performing ‘Tama’
(Calendar 2006
of Panhellenic Holy Foundation of Evangelistria of Tinos)

Fig. 7: The main church of Evangelismos in Tinos
and surroundings
(Calendar 2006 of Panhellenic Holy Foundation of
Evangelistria of Tinos)
|